Murder in a Cave in “Chili con Corpses”


Chili con CorpsesEllery Adams’s Chili con Corpses gives a creative third entry into her Supper Club series. The group have gotten bored of their diet, though all have lost significant weight, so the group is excited to join a cooking class to give themselves a break from the bland food they have been tired of. But Lucy, close to her goal of becoming a sheriff’s deputy, has been blowing off her friends, and even worse, her boyfriend, James. So when Lindy, the high school art teacher, gets the members of the Supper Club to help chaperone her field trip to a local cave for her students to study light and shadow, she becomes unhappy with Lucy for canceling in order not to miss her exercise class. Along with the four remaining members, the adults include the principal, a new teacher at the school, and the grandfather of one of the students. At the cave, James patrols his location, but then one of the students runs into him because she has found the new teacher, Kinsley Willis, murdered.

As the police begin to investigate, James and Lindy learn that the body was not that of Kinsley, the new teacher, but rather her identical twin sister, Parker, a veterinarian. What adds to the drama is the fact that Lindy harbors plenty of jealousy towards the very hot Kinsley because of both women’s interest in Principal Chavez, whom Lindy has wanted to ask out for years but has been waiting to get in better shape to impress the principal. But even more upsetting than the confusion over the identity of the murdered woman, they all suddenly realize that Mr. Sneed, the grandfather of student Adam, has not been seen since before the murder. And when the police call Adam’s parents, they learn that none of the boy’s grandparents were still alive, exposing the man as an imposter.

The night of the murder, after all the stress of his experience, James calls Lucy to ask her to join him at the bar. There they have a big fight, leading to the couple’s breaking up. What a miserable day for James! However, this break-up seems a God-send to Murphy, the editor of the local newspaper, who has long had romantic intentions towards James. Since Parker was Murphy’s college roommate, Murphy has a powerful desire to solve the murder of her good friend and enlists James to help her, as he did once before. This causes James internal conflict about which woman he truly wants: Lucy, whom he has dated for several months but who not only has been retreating from him and refusing to move their relationship move past the PG level, or Murphy, who clearly wants him and is eager to investigate with him.

I liked this addition to the Supper Club series. While the first two books were enjoyable, Chili con Corpses has a little extra spirit and plot to make it sparkle a bit more than the previous two. The murder plot was creative, with several interesting twists and angles to it. In addition, each member of the team contributes individually at times instead of completely as a unit, as they did in most of the previous two books.

I like the character development found in the book. The books in this series primarily use a third person limited point of view, focusing on the perspective of James, but this does shift away from that periodically. Personally, I would prefer a book to stick with either one style or the other, as the shift becomes a little discordant. But James does come across as a rounder character than he does in the previous two books. I like seeing the developing relationship between James and his father as well.

Karen White performs the audio version of this book. She creates strong voices for each character and effective inflections as she reads the book. My one complaint is that her voicing of Gary, a New Yorker, does not sound like the New York accents I am familiar with, though I admit not to having spent time in New York or with very many New Yorkers. But Gary does not speak many lines, so this was not a significant issue. Other than this, I liked the performance of White in this book.

Chili con Corpses was a very fun book. I thought it stronger than the first two in the series and really liked the conclusion. I am looking forward to the next book in the series. I give this book four stars.

To purchase this book for yourself, click here on Amazon.

Review Date
Reviewed Item
Chili con Corpses
Author Rating

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.