In Death below Stairs by Jennifer Ashley, set in 1881, Kat Holloway takes a position as cook in a high class mansion owned by Lord Rankin. She is pleased with her kitchen maid, Sinead, called by the family Ellen because hers is too fancy a name. But the second morning, Mrs. Holloway (all cooks and housekeepers were given the courtesy title of Mrs.) comes down to the kitchen to find the body of Sinead in the scullery, her head beaten to a pulp. Concerned that the murder will get written off as done by a vagabond, Mrs. Holloway summons a local man, Daniel McAdam, whom she hopes can help. The one challenge is that the man she is used to seeing as a local errand boy was with Lord Rankin in fine dress the night before. Who is Daniel really? Whatever he is, he has arranged to work in the manor and help look into the suspicious situation.
The book continues with mystery and intrigue, looking into the death of Sinead. Further, there is the mystery that has brought Daniel to the mansion of Lord Rankin in the first place. Things turn out to have national implications, perhaps even all the way to the throne of Queen Victoria.
I thoroughly enjoyed Death below Stairs, with its strong mystery, plenty of excitement, interesting historical details, and relatable characters. The plot has enough details of drama to keep us listening avidly. It is also interesting to hear about the life of a cook in a mansion in Victorian England. The bustle of the kitchen keeps Mrs. Holloway on her toes as she prepares meals for both the family and the servants. The illustrations of classes and issues of sexual morality that affect the employability of the serving class are very interesting.
I enjoyed the characters, who come across as real. Mrs. Holloway, the book’s narrator, is clearly the roundest. We see her reveal herself in small bits as the book progresses. Daniel proves to be an enigma to both Mrs. Holloway and us, the listeners, as he seems to move among all classes easily, making it hard to place who he truly is. My favorite character was Lady Cynthia, a woman who refuses to allow society’s dictates to control her, so she goes around in men’s clothing in an era when it was unthinkable for a woman to wear pants. She proves herself to be sharp and caring as well as independent, making me appreciate her a lot.
Anne-Marie Piazza performs the audio edition of this book. It took me a little while to get used to her voice, but once I got started listening, I got more comfortable with her voice. Piazza uses accents that convey a good sense of the various classes found in the London society. She also creates distinct voices for the different characters that make them come across clearly.
I thoroughly appreciated my experience listening to Death below Stairs. The book was fascinating and had a double set of mysteries that led to a real adventure. I enjoyed the creative characters and connected with them. I highly recommend this book to fans of historical mystery and give it five stars.
To purchase this book for yourself, click here on Amazon.
