It has been a couple weeks since I finished Hailey Piper’s All The Hearts You Eat, and I’m still not over that ending.
All the Hearts You Eat follows Ivory, a transwoman living in a coastal town in Massachusetts. Though the town of Cape Morning is bright and sunny for most during the Summer holidays, its far different for Cabrina Brite. During an attempt at a morning swim, Ivory discovers Cabrina’s body on the beach and a cryptic poem that could be both a suicide note, or maybe just a warning. Like Ivory, Cabrina was trans. However, Cabrina’s mother stopped at nothing to keep others from knowing what she saw as her “son’s” mental illness. Slowly, Ivory begins to discover that the nightmares she’s had are not too different from the random images Cabrina was seeing. Cabrina’s best friends, Xi and Rex, are both trying to uncover why their friend would do something so dramatic to escape her life, and also begin to unravel the mystery of the creatures that the small offshore island, Ghost Cat Island, may be hiding. This may not be a summer anyone in Cape Morning survives.
All The Hearts You Eat is violent, beautiful, and cathartic, especially for members of the Alphabet Mafia. There may be some readers out there wondering why all the main characters are part of the LGBT community, but I ask why the heck not? Hailey Piper treats her characters with a loving kindness that very few authors give their non-Cis characters. And still, they can and do get hurt. Each character has flaws, pasts, and bumps and bruises that make them feel like real people and not just the pages of a book. Do I want to protect every single teenager in this book? YES. Do I want to put a few of the parents in therapy? SURE. Is the ending a mind f**k that will take me a lot longer to get over? YOU BET.
All the Hears You Eat is brilliant and engaging. It is the type of book that I slowed down to read, devouring it in individual chapters because I just wanted to keep reading and discovering as many secrets as possible. Look for it now from Titan Books.

