We can’t have anything nice, can we?
Since I’m not allowed to talk about J.K. Rowling anymore, let’s talk about another love of mine and how human beings ruin everything. I like many millennials in desperate search for serotonin flocked to the Bon Appetit Test Kitchen’s Youtube page for loving little nuggets of joy from people that began to feel like a family. Brad Leone is everyone’s wacky uncle. Claire Saffitz is everyone’s put together aunt. Amiel is there for levity and style, and Delaney is an agent of chaos that we all love. Vinny and Hunzie were benevolent gods that wove the narrative together while Chris, Carla, Andy and others provided expert guidance and quips.
I love watching the patchwork family come together and I could quote lines from Brad and felt every single one of Claire’s nervous breakdowns. It was funny, relatable, educational and exactly what my depressed and anxious brain needed. If the views are to be believed; it was what millions of us needed.
That was before the fallout happened. That was before we learned of the racist past of the former Editor-in-Chief and the pay inequality between the white Youtube personalities and those of color. We had seen Sohla before many times; mostly saving Claire in an almost Magical Negro sort of way by being able to actually temper chocolate (something you can do in a microwave). We didn’t know that the chefs of color (Sohla, Priya, etc.) were not paid for their on-camera appearances. We assumed as an audience that of course they would be paid for their time spent mostly propping up white actors (like most minorities in media and frankly, in existence).
The fallout was immediate and intense once Sohla and the others went public with their very valid complaints and the other Bon Appetit chefs stood by in solidarity. We assumed this would mean change but we were very wrong. The recent news is that negotiations for more fair wages have not gone well and in continued solidarity many of our Bon Appetit favorites are not making video content until a fair deal is made. The choice seems so clear; just pay people fairly, but apparently that isn’t worth it if it means a company gets to dig its heels in firmly on the wrong side of the narrative.
So where do we go from here? How do we continue to navigate this situation ethically? When the story first broke, I couldn’t help but draw a parallel to how I was feeling about ol’ Auntie Jo and her blatant transphobia and how I could continue to grapple between my clear love of Harry Potter and my clear hatred of TERFs. How can you ethically be a fan of something that is so clearly wrong?
Well, for me, at least; I couldn’t keep watching Bon Appetit. I couldn’t in good faith keep going back to those videos which meant unsubscribing and trying to forget the love-language I had learned over time spent watching Brad fumble around with knives and Claire break down over tempering chocolate. It was easier to break away from this than it was to break from Harry Potter though I have made conscious efforts to wear my merch out less and to talk about it less as again, I cannot imagine ethically consuming the product anymore or aligning myself with someone who clearly opposes something I see as vital and not up for discussion.
You may decide that you want to continue to support Bon Appetit and you may find comfort watching reruns of Gourmet Makes or It’s Alive; and that’s fine, that’s your choice.
There is no clear path of where we go from here but I will close on this. We didn’t get here without people being brave and open and we didn’t get here without a lot of people making hard choices. For me as a consumer, it wasn’t that hard to unsubscribe from a Youtube channel but it took a lot of bravery for Sohla to come forward and lead the charge over what should be basic: equality and fair pay for work done.
Where we go from here is up to you. I know where I stand and that may change over time. But for now, the lines in the sand are drawn; where you go is up to you.

